New BMW i5 vs Lucid Air and Nio: Which Executive EV Comes Out on Top?

When it comes to executive electric vehicles, the competition has been heating up. In this article, we compare the new BMW i5, the Lucid Air, and the Nio ET7 to determine which one comes out on top. Let’s dive in.

Pre-Flight Briefing: BMW i5 M60

The BMW i5 is the latest addition to BMW’s electric vehicle lineup. This battery-propelled vehicle offers a rear-wheel-drive eDrive40 model, but we are focusing on the range-topping all-wheel-drive M60 xDrive. With a weight of 2.4 tonnes, it’s a hefty car, but it packs a punch.

• Price: £97,745 (£108,195 as tested)
• Powertrain: 81.2kWh battery, dual electric motors, all-wheel drive
• Performance: 593bhp, 586lb ft, 3.8sec 0-62mph, 143mph
• Weight: 2380kg
• Efficiency: 3.4 miles per kWh (official), 321-mile range (official), 0g/km CO2
• Length/width/height: 5060/1900/1515mm
• Boot capacity: 490 litres

Read our BMW i5 review here

Pre-Flight Briefing: Lucid Air Touring

The Lucid Air has been making waves in the industry, with multiple awards and glowing reviews. It offers sleek design and impressive engineering, making it the fastest and most efficient car in this comparison.

• Price: £111,727 (£116,491 as tested)
• Powertrain: 92kWh battery, dual electric motors, all-wheel drive
• Performance: 612bhp, 885lb ft, 3.2sec 0-62mph, 155mph
• Weight: 2200kg
• Efficiency: 4.9 miles per kWh (official), 450-mile range (official), 0g/km CO2
• Length/width/height: 4975/1936/1409mm
• Boot capacity: 625 litres + 283-litre frunk

Read our Lucid Air review here

Pre-Flight Briefing: Nio ET7

The Nio ET7 is the flagship saloon from Nio, a relatively new car company. With its powerful performance and range of autonomous driving features, the ET7 aims to impress.

• Price: £78,685 (£80,848 as tested)
• Powertrain: 90kWh battery, dual electric motors, all-wheel drive
• Performance: 644bhp, 627b ft, 3.8sec 0-62mph, 124mph
• Weight: 2454kg
• Efficiency: 3.3 miles per kWh (official), 360-mile range (official), 0g/km CO2
• Length/width/height: 5101/1987/1505mm
• Boot capacity: 364 litres

BMW i5 vs Lucid Air vs Nio ET7: The Test

In our test, we put these three electric vehicles through their paces to see how they compare in terms of performance, handling, comfort, and more.

Starting with the Lucid Air Touring, this car impressed with its acceleration and handling. It boasts 612bhp and can go from 0-62mph in just 3.2 seconds. The Air’s chassis is well-balanced, providing a comfortable yet engaging ride. On the other hand, the BMW i5 M60 offers solid performance and a more relaxed gait. It features advanced suspension technology, ensuring excellent body control and traction. Lastly, the Nio ET7 delivers impressive pace and a range of luxurious features, although some aspects of its interior feel less premium than its competitors.

When it comes to interiors, the Lucid Air sets a new standard. It offers luxurious materials, impeccable build quality, and a user-friendly touchscreen interface. The BMW i5’s interior is well-made and premium, while the Nio ET7 falls a bit short in terms of interior quality and functionality.

When it comes to practicality, the Lucid Air comes out on top with its spacious interior and generous boot space. The BMW i5 offers decent cargo capacity with a folding rear bench, while the Nio ET7 falls short with a small boot that lacks flexibility.

BMW i5 vs Lucid Air vs Nio ET7: The Final Reckoning

After evaluating these three electric executive vehicles, it’s clear that the Lucid Air comes out on top. With its impressive range, quick charging time, spacious interior, and exceptional handling, the Air surpasses its competitors. It offers a luxurious driving experience and sets a new benchmark for electric vehicles.

The BMW i5 comes in second place, offering solid performance, a comfortable ride, and a well-designed interior. Although it is more expensive, it delivers a satisfying driving experience.

The Nio ET7 takes third place, providing impressive acceleration and a range of features. However, its interior materials and lack of practicality hold it back from competing with the top two.

BMW i5 vs Lucid Air vs Nio ET7: The Verdict

First place: Lucid Air – A game-changer in the electric vehicle market, combining performance, luxury, and spaciousness.

Second place: BMW i5 – A solid contender with impressive technology and a comfortable ride.

Third place: Nio ET7 – While it offers impressive speed and features, it falls short in terms of interior quality and practicality.